These three private Catalina Island experiences suit very different trip styles: one is a customizable catamaran day, one is a small-group sailing trip centered on snorkeling, and one is a guided golf cart tour of Avalon. All three are private in format, but they differ clearly in route, pacing, transport, and the kind of time they put on the island or in the water.
TourPickGuide may earn a commission when you book through an affiliate link in this guide, at no extra cost to you.
This comparison is designed for travelers researching Catalina Island private tours. For related planning, see our TourPickGuide experience comparisons and USA tours and experiences.
Compare the 3 Tour Options
Use this comparison to match the itinerary, traveler feedback, duration, and key features to your preferred travel day.
| Tour | Best for | Rating | Reviews | Duration | Key point | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Custom private catamaran day | Travelers who want a private day that can be tailored with family or friends | ★ 5.0/5 | 94 reviews | Approx. 4 hr–8 hr | Private day format for your group only. | View on Viator |
 Private sailing and snorkeling | Travelers who want a small private sailing trip with snorkeling and onboard comfort | ★ 5.0/5 | 5 reviews | Approx. 6 hr 15 min | Very small private group size. | View on Viator |
 Private Avalon golf cart tour | Travelers who prefer a short guided tour of Avalon and its landmarks | ★ 4.9/5 | 631 reviews | Approx. 2 hr | Private guided transport by golf cart. | View on Viator |
Explore Each Tour in Detail
Each option includes its own photo gallery, overview, key features, traveler profile, and direct Viator link.
Choose this if you want the most adaptable private day on the water.
Private Luxury Catamaran – Saona or Catalina island
Best for: Travelers who want a private day that can be tailored with family or friends
This private catamaran experience is the most open-ended of the three. It is designed as a full day that you can help tailor, with the crew available to assist with the plan if you want guidance. The emphasis is on spending time with your own group rather than following a fixed sightseeing sequence. Confirmed inclusions cover hotel pickup and drop-off, a guide, snacks, drinks, and live commentary on board. It suits travelers who want a private boat day with room to adapt the pace, whether that means more social time, a looser island outing, or a combination of activities chosen in advance with the crew.
Flexible catamaran day for a made-to-order outing
- Private day format for your group only.
- Hotel pickup and drop-off are included.
- Food, drinks, and live commentary are confirmed inclusions.
Choose this if you want a private sailing day with snorkeling built in.
Private Luxury Sailing from Casa de Campo to Catalina Island
Best for: Travelers who want a small private sailing trip with snorkeling and onboard comfort
This option is built around a private sailing journey from Casa de Campo to Catalina Island, with a strong focus on the boat experience and time in the water. The group size is limited, which gives the trip a more intimate feel than a larger private outing. Confirmed inclusions cover private round-trip transportation from your hotel, a private sailing boat with captain, an open bar, light snacks, and the Casa de Campo entrance fee. The itinerary notes also point to snorkeling and exploring The Wall, so it will appeal to travelers who want a relaxed but active day with a clear marine focus rather than a city sightseeing format.
Small-scale sailing trip with a water-focused itinerary
- Very small private group size.
- Private round-trip transportation from your hotel is included.
- Snorkeling, light snacks, and an open bar are confirmed.
Choose this if you want a private guided look at Avalon rather than a boat outing.
Catalina Island Private Guided Golf Cart Tour of Avalon
Best for: Travelers who prefer a short guided tour of Avalon and its landmarks
This is the most land-based and itinerary-specific of the three experiences. Instead of a boat day, it uses a private golf cart to explore Avalon with a local guide, which makes it a straightforward choice for travelers who want commentary and a tighter sightseeing window. The confirmed inclusions are private transportation, bottled water, and landing and facility fees. The tour notes also point to a set of local stops and viewpoints, so it is best understood as a guided overview of Avalon rather than a flexible open day. It works well for visitors who want a shorter private experience with a clear sightseeing structure and less time commitment.
Guided golf cart sightseeing for a concentrated Avalon visit
- Private guided transport by golf cart.
- Bottled water and landing and facility fees are included.
- It is a short, focused tour with advance reservation emphasized.
How to Choose Your Catalina Island Itinerary Style
If you want a private day that feels adaptable and social, the catamaran format gives you the most room to shape the outing. If you want a small, water-centered experience, the sailing trip is the most focused on snorkeling and time aboard the boat. If your priority is seeing Avalon efficiently with a guide, the golf cart tour is the most direct fit.
Private catamaran with a customizable island day
A private boat day that can be shaped around the spots and activities you prefer.
Private sailing to Catalina Island from Casa de Campo
A private sail with snorkeling and onboard refreshments, centered on the water and reef environment.
Private golf cart tour of Avalon
A private guided ride through Avalon for travelers who want a compact sightseeing format.
Travel planning tip
Check the live product page before booking. Departure details, activity order, inclusions, and available options can change.
Booking notes
- Check the confirmed inclusions carefully before booking, especially when comparing transport, drinks, and fees.
- Private group size and pace vary by experience, so choose the format that matches how much structure you want.
- Because the experiences differ by route and activity style, reserve early if your travel dates or preferred time are limited.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which option is the most flexible?
The private catamaran day is the most flexible because the outing is described as something your group can tailor with help from the crew.
Which option is best for snorkeling?
The private sailing trip from Casa de Campo to Catalina Island is the clearest fit because snorkeling is explicitly part of the experience notes.
Which option is shortest and most sightseeing-focused?
The private guided golf cart tour of Avalon is the shortest option and is built around local sightseeing with a guide.