These three day-trip styles from Cruz Bay are all private or small-group outings built around St. Thomas and nearby waters. One is a boat charter, and the other two are Jeep-based island excursions with different levels of structure and customization.
TourPickGuide may earn a commission when you book through an affiliate link in this guide, at no extra cost to you.
This comparison is designed for travelers researching day trips from Cruz Bay. For related planning, see our TourPickGuide experience comparisons and US Virgin Islands tours and experiences.
Compare the 3 Tour Options
Use this comparison to match the itinerary, traveler feedback, duration, and key features to your preferred travel day.
| Tour | Best for | Rating | Reviews | Duration | Key point | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Private boat charter | Travelers who want a captain-led private day and the freedom to shape a boat outing around their own interests. | ★ 5.0/5 | 35 reviews | Not listed | Private charter keeps the outing limited to your group and captain. | View on Viator |
 Structured Jeep tour | Travelers who want a full island day with frequent stops, overland scenery, and a more guided sightseeing format. | ★ 5.0/5 | 14 reviews | Approx. 8 hr | The tour format is more structured, with frequent stops along the way. | View on Viator |
 Private custom Jeep | Travelers who want a private Jeep day with more control over the route, pickup style, and overall pace. | ★ 4.9/5 | 34 reviews | Approx. 7 hr | Private transportation is confirmed. | View on Viator |
Explore Each Tour in Detail
Each option includes its own photo gallery, overview, key features, traveler profile, and direct Viator link.
Water-focused private charter
St Thomas Full-Day Boat Rental 37' Intrepid Powerboat
Best for: Travelers who want a captain-led private day and the freedom to shape a boat outing around their own interests.
This experience is a full-day private boat charter on a 37-foot powerboat. The format is flexible: your group goes out with a captain, and the day can be customized instead of following a set sightseeing schedule. Confirmed inclusions include a captain, snorkel equipment, bottled water, and a cooler with ice and water. The listing also notes a sound system with iPod hookup. It is a strong fit for travelers who want an unhurried water day and prefer to decide the pace with guidance from the captain rather than follow a fixed land itinerary.
Private boat day with a captain
- Private charter keeps the outing limited to your group and captain.
- Confirmed snorkel gear and bottled water are included.
- A cooler with ice and water is provided for the day.
Land-based sightseeing day
Full Day Jeep Tours and Excursions on St. Thomas
Best for: Travelers who want a full island day with frequent stops, overland scenery, and a more guided sightseeing format.
This is a full-day Jeep tour on St. Thomas that is described as action packed and centered on sightseeing, exploration, and custom stops. The itinerary notes mention frequent photo and overlook stops, and the overall format suggests a guided land experience rather than a single destination transfer. Confirmed inclusions include beach chairs, bottled water, soda, beer, and snorkel equipment. The listing also says guests may stop to eat lunch at restaurants or bring lunches for the beach, but meal purchase is not a confirmed inclusion. It suits travelers who want a busy, varied day on land with a guided route and many stops.
Full-day Jeep sightseeing and exploration
- The tour format is more structured, with frequent stops along the way.
- Beach chairs, water, soda, and beer are confirmed.
- Snorkel equipment is included with the outing.
Private customized island day
Island Life Jeep Tours – Your Day Your Way Private Excursion!
Best for: Travelers who want a private Jeep day with more control over the route, pickup style, and overall pace.
This experience is a private Jeep excursion on St. Thomas with a flexible, personalized approach. The itinerary is arranged with the driver the morning of the tour, so it is less fixed than a standard sightseeing route and more focused on your group’s interests. Confirmed inclusions include private transportation, swim vests, snorkel equipment, beach chairs, a cooler, water, soda, juice, and unlimited rum and vodka mixers. The listing also mentions multiple pickup or drop-off choices, including private villa pickup. It is a good match for travelers who want privacy and a more tailored day rather than a set group schedule.
Private Jeep tour shaped around your group
- Private transportation is confirmed.
- The tour is customized the morning of the outing.
- Snorkel equipment, beach chairs, and drinks are included.
How to choose a Cruz Bay day trip style
If you want the most open-ended day, choose the private boat charter or the private Jeep tour. If you prefer a more guided sightseeing plan with regular stops, the full-day Jeep excursion is the closer fit.
Custom USVI or BVI boat charter
The listed option is a full-day charter with pickup included.
St. Thomas Jeep excursion
The listed option is a full-day 8-hour tour with pickup included.
Private St. Thomas Jeep excursion
The listed option is a private approximately 7-hour excursion with pickup included.
Travel planning tip
Check the live product page before booking. Departure details, activity order, inclusions, and available options can change.
Booking notes
- Confirmed inclusions differ by product, so check each listing carefully before booking.
- Pickup is mentioned in the supplied options, but the exact arrangement depends on the product.
- Some extras are excluded or only described as possible purchases, so plan separately for anything not explicitly included.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which option is most flexible for a custom itinerary?
The private boat charter and the private Jeep tour are both customizable, while the standard Jeep excursion follows a more structured sightseeing format.
Which trip is better if I want to stay on the water?
The boat rental is the only water-based option here and is the best match for travelers who want a private day afloat with a captain.
Which experience is easiest to compare by included gear and drinks?
The Jeep tours list the clearest land-based inclusions, while the boat charter confirms snorkel gear, bottled water, and a cooler with ice and water.